Dubai: A man filed a lawsuit before the Dubai Civil Court of First Instance seeking the return of about Dh110.66 million, which he said represented his share of funds withdrawn by his ex-wife from their joint bank account. The court ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the case.
The case arose from a marriage that ended in divorce. During their marriage, the couple opened a joint bank account containing deposits in several currencies.
The husband said the terms and conditions of the account stipulated that the two parties would jointly own all funds deposited into it in equal shares, regardless of who made the deposits.
He said the defendant made withdrawals and transfers totalling about Dh221 million, which he claimed exceeded her share of the jointly owned funds. He sought half of that amount.
The husband based his claim on a report by an expert consultant, which he said showed the amount his ex-wife had withdrawn or transferred in excess of her share. He also submitted copies of the bank account opening documents and account statements, as well as the couple’s divorce decree.
He argued that, under the agreement between the parties and the account’s terms, the deposited funds had ceased to be individually owned and had become joint property. He said neither party was entitled to dispose of the other’s share or take more than their own share without consent or an agreed division and settlement of the funds.
The ex-wife argued that the Dubai courts lacked jurisdiction and asked for the case to be dismissed on its merits. As a precaution, she also requested the appointment of a three-member expert committee and reserved her right to seek the return of funds she alleged the plaintiff had unlawfully taken.
She submitted documents including identity details, a passport, a family registration extract and a certificate from her employer and workplace.
She also relied on previous court rulings in family disputes between the couple, which she said had concluded that the Dubai courts lacked jurisdiction to hear them. She submitted copies of those judgments and correspondence with the plaintiff, which she said showed that he had been added to the joint account for purposes related to visa procedures.
Jurisdiction
After considering the case, the court examined the challenge to its jurisdiction.
It said the applicable legal rule required a case to be heard by the court within whose jurisdiction the defendant is domiciled, unless otherwise provided by law. A challenge to jurisdiction may be raised at any stage of proceedings, and the court must consider the issue on its own initiative because it relates to public order.
The court said jurisdiction was an issue that had to be resolved before considering the substance of the dispute.
After reviewing the case documents, it found that the defendant lived at her parents’ home and worked in the same area. The court found no evidence that she had a domicile, residence or workplace in Dubai.
The court rejected the plaintiff’s argument that his ex-wife had a chosen domicile in Dubai, explaining that such a domicile must be specified in writing and identify the legal matter for which it was selected. The court found that this had not been established in the case.
It also said the plaintiff was not seeking damages, with his claim limited to the return of money he alleged his ex-wife had withdrawn from the joint account.
The court accepted the challenge to its jurisdiction and ruled, in the presence of both parties, that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the case.
It ordered the plaintiff to pay 10 per cent of the court fees.
Source: Emirates 24|7

